Three Arguments Based


Statement - Arguments - Concepts
Class - Bank Clerical Prelims Subjects
 
 
Concept Explanation
 

Three Arguments Based

Introduction : An argument is a statement meant to convince another person about your point of view. In these types of questions, your personal biases and opinions or any prior knowledge about the subject matter should never be considered. Here, you are given a statement followed by a set of arguments related to that statement. These arguments may support or contradict the statement. You are expected to assess whether each argument is strong or weak.

Concept of Strong and Weak Arguments : -

  • Strong Argument An argument is a strong one, if it is directly related to the given statement and the reason given in the argument addresses all the points put forward in the given statement.
  • Weak Argument An argument is a weak one, if it is not directly related to the given statement and it does not address all the points put forward in the given statement.
  • Points to keep in mind while solving and practicing these questions.

  • While you make a decision about the important questions, it is desirable to be able to differentiate between ‘strong’ and ‘weak’ arguments so far as they relate to the questions.
  • For ‘weak’ arguments, the most important thing to note is that they may or may not be directly related to the question and may be of minor importance.
  • Then based on the question, you have to determine which argument is strong and which one is weak.
  • Points taken into consideration while choosing a strong or a weak argument.

    Strong Arguments are : 

  • supported by established fact/experiences/logic/ prevailing notions of truth.
  • correct.
  • desirable (or harmful in case of negative argument).
  • properly related with the statement.
  • Weak Arguments are

  • ambiguous or confusing arguments.
  • too simple to be arguments.
  • goes against established facts.
  • does not get support from past experiences.
  • does not get support from logic and common sense.
  • assumption based arguments.
  • goes against prevailing notions of truth.
  • Three Arguments Based : Here, we are given three arguments and we have to study them, find which is/are true ?

    Direction : The question given below consists of a statement, followed by three arguments numbered I, II and III. you have to decide which of the arguments is/are 'strong' argument (s) and which is/are 'weak' argument (s) and accordingly choose your answer from the alternatives given below the question ?

    Question :

    Statement : Should all the students graduating in any disciplines desirous of pursuing post-graduation in the subjects of their choice be allowed to enroll themselves in the post-graduate courses?

    Arguments :

  • I. Yes, the students are the best judge of their capabilities and they should not be restricted from joining post-graduation courses.
  • II. No, the students need to study relevant subjects in graduate courses to enroll in post-graduate courses and the students must fulfil such conditions.
  • III. No, there are not enough institutes offering post-graduate courses which can  accommodate all the graduates desirous of seeking post-graduation education of their own choice.
  • (a) I and III are strong                        (b) Only I is strong                     (c) Only II is strong                                    (d) None is strong

    Solution (c) : The students cannot be enrolled in the courses just on the basis of their interests but their compatibility with the same also matters. So, Argument I does not hold. Besides, lack of institutions is no criteria to deny post-graduate Courses to students. Hence, Argument IIl does not hold. But Argument II holds as it is a genuine reason,

    Sample Questions
    (More Questions for each concept available in Login)
    Question : 1

    Directions : Question given below consists of a statement, followed by three or four arguments numbered I, II, III and IV. You have to decided which of the arguments is/are 'strong' argument (s) and which is / are 'weak' argument (s) and accordingly choose your answer from the alternatives given below the question.

    Statement : Should there be a complete ban on genetically modified imported seeds ?

    Arguments :

    I. Yes. This will boost the demand of domestically developed seeds.

    II. No. This is the only way to increase production substantially.

    III. Yes. Genetically modified products will adversely affect the health of those who consume these products.

    Right Option : B
    View Explanation
    Explanation
    Question : 2

    Directions : The question given below consists of a statement, followed by three or four arguments numbered I, II, III and IV. You have to decided which of the arguments is / are 'strong' argument (s) and which is / are 'weak' argument (s) and accordingly choose your answer from the alternatives given below each question.

    Statement : Should India immediately stop digging coal from its mines ?

    Arguments :

    I. Yes. The present stock of coal will not last long if we continue mining at the present rate.

    II. No. We do not have alternate energy source of sufficient quantity.

    III. No. This will put millions of people at a disadvantage and their lives will get adversely affected and also the industry.

    Right Option : B
    View Explanation
    Explanation
    Question : 3

    Directions : The problem given below consists of a statement, followed by three or four arguments numbered I, II, III and IV. You have to decided which of the arguments is / are 'strong' argument (s) and which is / are 'weak' argument (s) and accordingly choose your answer from the alternatives given below each question.

    Statement : Should the income generated out agricultural activities be taxed ?

    Arguments :

    I. No. Framers are otherwise suffering from natural calamities and low yield coupled with low procurement price and their income should not be taxed.

    II. Yes. Majority of the population is dependent on agriculture and hence their income should be taxed to augment the resources.

    III. Yes. Many big farmers earn much more than the majority of the service earners and they should be taxed to removed the disparity.

    Right Option : C
    View Explanation
    Explanation
     
     
     


    Students / Parents Reviews [10]